Which Day Trip Should You Choose from Phuket?
Phang Nga Bay and Phi Phi Island are the two most popular day trips from Phuket, but they offer completely different experiences. I’ve done both trips dozens of times over 30 years, and the honest answer is: it depends on what you want from your day. Phang Nga Bay is about dramatic scenery, limestone cliffs, sea cave kayaking, and calm waters. You won’t find beaches here, but the landscape is unlike anywhere else in Thailand. It’s sheltered from monsoons, so tours run year-round without cancellations.
Phi Phi Island is about beaches, snorkelling, clear blue water, and the famous Maya Bay from “The Beach.” The scenery is beautiful, but the boat ride is longer, and the sea can get rough during the low season. Expect more crowds, especially at Maya Bay. If you only have time for one tour, this guide will help you decide. If you have two days, do both. They’re different enough to justify it.
Quick Summary
| Factor | Phang Nga Bay | Phi Phi Island |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Scenery, kayaking, photography | Beaches, snorkelling, swimming |
| Famous for | James Bond Island, limestone karsts | Maya Bay, The Beach movie |
| Beaches | Few small beaches, not the focus | Multiple white sand beaches |
| Main activity | Sea cave kayaking | Snorkelling and swimming |
| Travel time from Phuket | 45 min by speedboat | 90 min by speedboat |
| Sea conditions | Calm year-round (sheltered bay) | Can be rough May–October |
| Tour cancellations | Rare | Common in low season |
| Crowds | Busy at James Bond Island only | Busy at Maya Bay and Pileh Lagoon |
| Tour price | 1,500–3,500 Baht | 1,800–4,000 Baht |
| Best time to visit | Year-round | November–April |
Choose Phang Nga Bay If…
Phang Nga Bay is the better choice if you want dramatic scenery and a more relaxed day on the water. The limestone karsts rising from emerald water are spectacular, and kayaking through sea caves into hidden lagoons is something you won’t experience anywhere else in Thailand. It’s also the safer choice during monsoon season. The mainland shelters the bay, so the water stays calm even when Phi Phi tours get cancelled. Families with young children or anyone prone to seasickness will have an easier time here.
See the tours available
Choose Phi Phi Island If…
Phi Phi is the better choice if you want beaches, snorkelling, and time in the water. The sand is white, the water is clear blue, and the marine life is more colourful than anything you’ll see in Phang Nga Bay. If seeing Maya Bay matters to you, this is obviously the trip to take. Just know that it gets crowded, and you’re limited to about one hour on the beach. The boat ride is longer and rougher, so don’t book this if the weather looks bad.
See the tours available
Can You Do Both in One Day?
Some tour operators offer combined trips, but I don’t recommend them. You’ll spend most of the day on a boat and barely have time to enjoy either destination. The two locations are in opposite directions from Phuket, so combining them means a lot of backtracking. If you have two full days for tours, do them separately. If you only have one day, pick the experience that matches what you want.
Conclusion?
After 30 years of doing both trips, I’d pick Phang Nga Bay almost every time. It’s more unique, more authentically Thai, and the scenery never gets old, no matter how many times I go. The limestone karsts, the hidden lagoons, the sea caves, it’s unlike anywhere else in the world.
Phi Phi is beautiful, but let’s be honest: most people go for that one photo of Maya Bay. What they don’t expect is the boat traffic jam getting there, the crowded beach, and the strict one-hour time limit. If you’ve seen “The Beach” and must tick it off your list, go for it. But if you want a day trip that actually feels special, Phang Nga Bay is the better choice.
Pro Tip: Don’t book the cheapest tour. Spend a bit more for a quality operator that leaves earlier or later than the big groups. Phang Nga Bay is huge, and if you time it right, you’ll have the lagoons and caves almost to yourself while the crowds are stuck at James Bond Island taking selfies.
More about Phang Nga Bay
